Authors/Ockham/Summa Logicae/Book III-3: Difference between revisions

From The Logic Museum
Jump to navigation Jump to search
 
(48 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 7: Line 7:
{{Translation codes}}
{{Translation codes}}
==Chapters 1-37: on Aristotle's ''Topics''==
==Chapters 1-37: on Aristotle's ''Topics''==
*[[/Chapter 1|Chapter 1]] {{Translated not checked}}Of the mode of arguing by consequences, and arguments which do not have syllogistic form. And first, how many modes are there of so-called consequences?</span>
*[[/Chapter 1|Chapter 1]] {{Checked by translator}}Of the mode of arguing by consequences, and arguments which do not have syllogistic form. And first, how many modes are there of so-called consequences?</span>
*[[/Chapter 2|Chapter 2]] {{Translated not checked}}On the general rules by which consequences hold through an intrensic medium and conclude a universal.</span>
*[[/Chapter 2|Chapter 2]] {{Checked by translator}}On the general rules by which consequences hold through an intrensic medium and conclude a universal.</span>
*[[/Chapter 3|Chapter 3]] {{Translated not checked}}On the Rules by which the Universal Affirmative is inferred with respect to determined Predicates. </span>
*[[/Chapter 3|Chapter 3]] {{Checked by translator}}On the Rules by which the Universal Affirmative is inferred with respect to determined Predicates. </span>
*[[/Chapter 4|Chapter 4]] {{Translated not checked}}Concerning the rules by which consequences inferring the universal negative hold. </span>
*[[/Chapter 4|Chapter 4]] {{Checked by translator}}Concerning the rules by which consequences inferring the universal negative hold. </span>
*[[/Chapter 5|Chapter 5]] {{Translated not checked}}Concerning the rules which are not observed with respect to any predicates. </span>
*[[/Chapter 5|Chapter 5]] {{Checked by translator}}Concerning the rules which are not observed with respect to any predicates. </span>
*[[/Chapter 6|Chapter 6]] {{Translated not checked}}On the rules that govern the consequences between particulars or indefinites.</span>
*[[/Chapter 6|Chapter 6]] {{Checked by translator}}On the rules that govern the consequences between particulars or indefinites.</span>
*[[/Chapter 7|Chapter 7]] {{Translated not checked}}On the rules of inferring an affirmative from an affirmative through an external medium. </span>
*[[/Chapter 7|Chapter 7]] {{Checked by translator}}On the rules of inferring an affirmative from an affirmative through an external medium. </span>
*[[/Chapter 8|Chapter 8]] {{Translated not checked}}Concerning the rules by which the consequences hold that infer the negative from the negative. </span>
*[[/Chapter 8|Chapter 8]] {{Checked by translator}}Concerning the rules by which the consequences hold that infer the negative from the negative. </span>
*[[/Chapter 9|Chapter 9]] {{Translated not checked}}On the rules governing consequences inferring a negative from a positive or the converse.  
*[[/Chapter 9|Chapter 9]] {{Checked by translator}}On the rules governing consequences inferring a negative from a positive or the converse.  
*[[/Chapter 10|Chapter 10]] {{Translated not checked}}On the rules governing consequences following from modal propositions; and first when both the antecedent and the consequence are in the same mode.
*[[/Chapter 10|Chapter 10]] {{Checked by translator}}On the rules governing consequences following from modal propositions; and first when both the antecedent and the consequence are in the same mode.
*[[/Chapter 11|Chapter 11]] {{Translated not checked}}Chapter 11. On the rules that govern consequences from one proposition of essence and another of a mode.
*[[/Chapter 11|Chapter 11]] {{Checked by translator}}On the rules that govern consequences from one proposition of essence and another of a mode.
*[[/Chapter 12|Chapter 12]] {{Translated not checked}}On the rules by which the consequences hold that are made from propositions of different modes
*[[/Chapter 12|Chapter 12]] {{Checked by translator}}On the rules by which the consequences hold that are made from propositions of different modes
*[[/Chapter 13|Chapter 13]] {{Translated not checked}}On the comparison of the modes for conversion.
*[[/Chapter 13|Chapter 13]] {{Checked by translator}}On the comparison of the modes for conversion.
*[[/Chapter 14|Chapter 14]] {{Translated not checked}}Concerning the equivalent propositions in which the 'necessary' mode is placed.  
*[[/Chapter 14|Chapter 14]] {{Checked by translator}}Concerning the equivalent propositions in which the 'necessary' mode is placed.  
*[[/Chapter 15|Chapter 15]] {{Translated not checked}}Chapter 15. On the opposition and contingency of propositions of contingency.  
*[[/Chapter 15|Chapter 15]] {{Checked by translator}}On the opposition and contingency of propositions of contingency.  
*[[/Chapter 16|Chapter 16]] {{Translated not checked}}On the equivalence of propositions about the impossible.  
*[[/Chapter 16|Chapter 16]] {{Checked by translator}}On the equivalence of propositions about the impossible.  
*[[/Chapter 17|Chapter 17]] {{Translated not checked}}On the rules that govern consequences in which some terms supposit simply or materially.
*[[/Chapter 17|Chapter 17]] {{Checked by translator}}On the rules that govern consequences in which some terms supposit simply or materially.
*[[/Chapter 18|Chapter 18]] {{Translated not checked}}On the rules by which problems of genera are constructed or decomposed.
*[[/Chapter 18|Chapter 18]] {{Checked by translator}}On the rules by which problems of genera are constructed or decomposed.
*[[/Chapter 19|Chapter 19]] {{Translated not checked}}On the rules by which it is inferred that some thing is a property of another.  
*[[/Chapter 19|Chapter 19]] {{Checked by translator}}On the rules by which it is inferred that some thing is a property of another.  
*[[/Chapter 20|Chapter 20]] {{Translated not checked}}On the rules by which it is inferred that something is or is not a property of something else.  
*[[/Chapter 20|Chapter 20]] {{Checked by translator}}On the rules by which it is inferred that something is or is not a property of something else.  
*[[/Chapter 21|Chapter 21]] {{Translated not checked}}On the property that is composed of genus and accidental differences.  
*[[/Chapter 21|Chapter 21]] {{Checked by translator}}On the property that is composed of genus and accidental differences.  
*[[/Chapter 22|Chapter 22]] {{Translated not checked}}On definition: What is it?  
*[[/Chapter 22|Chapter 22]] {{Checked by translator}}On definition: What is it?  
*[[/Chapter 23|Chapter 23]] {{Translated not checked}}In how many modes a definition is stated  
*[[/Chapter 23|Chapter 23]] {{Checked by translator}}In how many modes a definition is stated  
*[[/Chapter 24|Chapter 24]] {{Translated not checked}}On the rules that govern the consequences by which something is inferred to be the definition of another.  
*[[/Chapter 24|Chapter 24]] {{Checked by translator}}On the rules that govern the consequences by which something is inferred to be the definition of another.  
*[[/Chapter 25|Chapter 25]] {{Translated not checked}}On definition given by addendum.  
*[[/Chapter 25|Chapter 25]] {{Checked by translator}}On definition given by addendum.  
*[[/Chapter 26|Chapter 26]] {{Translated not checked}}On the definition expressing what a term means.  
*[[/Chapter 26|Chapter 26]] {{Checked by translator}}On the definition expressing what a term means.  
*[[/Chapter 27|Chapter 27]] {{Translated not checked}}On the rules by which something can be proved to be a species of something else.  
*[[/Chapter 27|Chapter 27]] {{Checked by translator}}On the rules by which something can be proved to be a species of something else.  
*[[/Chapter 28|Chapter 28]]
*[[/Chapter 28|Chapter 28]] {{Checked by translator}}On the rules by which it can be proved that womething is different from another thing.
*[[/Chapter 29|Chapter 29]] {{Translated not checked}}On same and different.  
*[[/Chapter 29|Chapter 29]] {{Checked by translator}}On same and different.  
*[[/Chapter 30|Chapter 30]] {{Translated not checked}}On the rules governing consequences that are the same and different.  
*[[/Chapter 30|Chapter 30]] {{Checked by translator}}On the rules governing consequences that are the same and different.  
===On induction===
===On induction===
*[[/Chapter 31|Chapter 31]] {{Translated not checked}}On the species of argument called 'induction'</span>
*[[/Chapter 31|Chapter 31]] {{Checked by translator}}On the species of argument called 'induction'</span>
*[[/Chapter 32|Chapter 32]] {{Translated not checked}}How induction comes about in assertoric propositions</span>
*[[/Chapter 32|Chapter 32]] {{Checked by translator}}How induction comes about in assertoric propositions</span>
*[[/Chapter 33|Chapter 33]] {{Translated not checked}}On the induction of universal modal propositions</span>
*[[/Chapter 33|Chapter 33]] {{Checked by translator}}On the induction of universal modal propositions</span>
*[[/Chapter 34|Chapter 34]] {{Translated not checked}}How singular modal propositions in the sense of composition are related to universal modal propositions in the sense of composition</span>
*[[/Chapter 34|Chapter 34]] {{Checked by translator}}How singular modal propositions in the sense of composition are related to universal modal propositions in the sense of composition</span>
*[[/Chapter 35|Chapter 35]] {{Translated not checked}}On the induction of universal ''de possibili' propositions</span>
*[[/Chapter 35|Chapter 35]] {{Checked by translator}}On the induction of universal ''de possibili' propositions</span>
*[[/Chapter 36|Chapter 36]] {{Translated not checked}}On the induction of universal ''de contintenti' propositions</span>
*[[/Chapter 36|Chapter 36]] {{Checked by translator}}On the induction of universal ''de contintenti' propositions</span>
*[[/Chapter 37|Chapter 37]] {{Translated not checked}}On the rules by which something can be proved to be equivocal</span>
*[[/Chapter 37|Chapter 37]] {{Checked by translator}}On the rules by which something can be proved to be equivocal</span>


==Chapters 38-45: ''Obligationes''==
==Chapters 38-45: ''Obligationes''==
*[[/Chapter 38|Chapter 38]] {{Translated not checked}}On general and commonly used rules
*[[/Chapter 38|Chapter 38]] {{Checked by translator}}On general and commonly used rules
*[[/Chapter 39|Chapter 39]] {{Translated not checked}}On the rules that pertain to the obligatory art. And first about institution.  
*[[/Chapter 39|Chapter 39]] {{Checked by translator}}On the rules that pertain to the obligatory art. And first about institution.  
*[[/Chapter 40|Chapter 40]] {{Translated not checked}}On the second type of obligation, which is called petition.
*[[/Chapter 40|Chapter 40]] {{Checked by translator}}On the second type of obligation, which is called petition.
*[[/Chapter 41|Chapter 41]] {{Translated not checked}}On the third type of obligation, which is called position. How is it different from case?  
*[[/Chapter 41|Chapter 41]] {{Checked by translator}}On the third type of obligation, which is called position. How is it different from case?  
*[[/Chapter 42|Chapter 42]] {{Translated not checked}}What is a position of the impossible?
*[[/Chapter 42|Chapter 42]] {{Checked by translator}}What is a position of the impossible?
*[[/Chapter 43|Chapter 43]] {{Translated not checked}}On the fourth type of obligation, which is called deposition.
*[[/Chapter 43|Chapter 43]] {{Checked by translator}}On the fourth type of obligation, which is called deposition.
*[[/Chapter 44|Chapter 44]] {{Translated not checked}}On the fifth type of obligation, qhuch is called uncertainty.  
*[[/Chapter 44|Chapter 44]] {{Checked by translator}}On the fifth type of obligation, qhuch is called uncertainty.  
*[[/Chapter 45|Chapter 45]] {{Translated not checked}}Of the sixth type of obligation, in which it is posited 'let it be true'.
*[[/Chapter 45|Chapter 45]] {{Checked by translator}}Of the sixth type of obligation, in which it is posited 'let it be true'.


==Chapter 46: on the ''Liar'' paradox==
==Chapter 46: on the ''Liar'' paradox==
*[[/Chapter 46|Chapter 46]] {{Translated not checked}}On insolubles.
*[[/Chapter 46|Chapter 46]] {{Checked by translator}}On insolubles.

Latest revision as of 17:58, 2 April 2025


PART III-3: OF CONSEQUENCES

Colour codes

Chapter headings are colour coded to indicate the stage of the translation process. 'Reviewed' means that another competent translator has checked the work section by section. 'Authorised' means that a member of a specialist panel has reviewed the whole translation, and approved it.

Chapters 1-37: on Aristotle's Topics

  • Chapter 1 Of the mode of arguing by consequences, and arguments which do not have syllogistic form. And first, how many modes are there of so-called consequences?
  • Chapter 2 On the general rules by which consequences hold through an intrensic medium and conclude a universal.
  • Chapter 3 On the Rules by which the Universal Affirmative is inferred with respect to determined Predicates.
  • Chapter 4 Concerning the rules by which consequences inferring the universal negative hold.
  • Chapter 5 Concerning the rules which are not observed with respect to any predicates.
  • Chapter 6 On the rules that govern the consequences between particulars or indefinites.
  • Chapter 7 On the rules of inferring an affirmative from an affirmative through an external medium.
  • Chapter 8 Concerning the rules by which the consequences hold that infer the negative from the negative.
  • Chapter 9 On the rules governing consequences inferring a negative from a positive or the converse.
  • Chapter 10 On the rules governing consequences following from modal propositions; and first when both the antecedent and the consequence are in the same mode.
  • Chapter 11 On the rules that govern consequences from one proposition of essence and another of a mode.
  • Chapter 12 On the rules by which the consequences hold that are made from propositions of different modes
  • Chapter 13 On the comparison of the modes for conversion.
  • Chapter 14 Concerning the equivalent propositions in which the 'necessary' mode is placed.
  • Chapter 15 On the opposition and contingency of propositions of contingency.
  • Chapter 16 On the equivalence of propositions about the impossible.
  • Chapter 17 On the rules that govern consequences in which some terms supposit simply or materially.
  • Chapter 18 On the rules by which problems of genera are constructed or decomposed.
  • Chapter 19 On the rules by which it is inferred that some thing is a property of another.
  • Chapter 20 On the rules by which it is inferred that something is or is not a property of something else.
  • Chapter 21 On the property that is composed of genus and accidental differences.
  • Chapter 22 On definition: What is it?
  • Chapter 23 In how many modes a definition is stated
  • Chapter 24 On the rules that govern the consequences by which something is inferred to be the definition of another.
  • Chapter 25 On definition given by addendum.
  • Chapter 26 On the definition expressing what a term means.
  • Chapter 27 On the rules by which something can be proved to be a species of something else.
  • Chapter 28 On the rules by which it can be proved that womething is different from another thing.
  • Chapter 29 On same and different.
  • Chapter 30 On the rules governing consequences that are the same and different.

On induction

  • Chapter 31 On the species of argument called 'induction'
  • Chapter 32 How induction comes about in assertoric propositions
  • Chapter 33 On the induction of universal modal propositions
  • Chapter 34 How singular modal propositions in the sense of composition are related to universal modal propositions in the sense of composition
  • Chapter 35 On the induction of universal de possibili' propositions
  • Chapter 36 On the induction of universal de contintenti' propositions
  • Chapter 37 On the rules by which something can be proved to be equivocal

Chapters 38-45: Obligationes

  • Chapter 38 On general and commonly used rules
  • Chapter 39 On the rules that pertain to the obligatory art. And first about institution.
  • Chapter 40 On the second type of obligation, which is called petition.
  • Chapter 41 On the third type of obligation, which is called position. How is it different from case?
  • Chapter 42 What is a position of the impossible?
  • Chapter 43 On the fourth type of obligation, which is called deposition.
  • Chapter 44 On the fifth type of obligation, qhuch is called uncertainty.
  • Chapter 45 Of the sixth type of obligation, in which it is posited 'let it be true'.

Chapter 46: on the Liar paradox