Authors/Ockham/Summa Logicae/Book III-2: Difference between revisions

From The Logic Museum
Jump to navigation Jump to search
No edit summary
 
(51 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 8: Line 8:
{{Translation codes}}
{{Translation codes}}
==Terms and the conditions required of them in order that their propositions form part of demonstration==
==Terms and the conditions required of them in order that their propositions form part of demonstration==
*[[/Chapter 1|Chapter 1]] {{Translated not checked}}What is understood by the term "demonstration," and in how many ways is "to know" predicated?</span>
*[[/Chapter 1|Chapter 1]] {{Checked by translator}}What is understood by the term "demonstration," and in how many ways is "to know" predicated?</span>
*[[/Chapter 2|Chapter 2]] {{Translated not checked}}What terms are included in a demonstration?</span>
*[[/Chapter 2|Chapter 2]] {{Checked by translator}}What terms are included in a demonstration?</span>
*[[/Chapter 3|Chapter 3]] {{Translated not checked}}What does a demonstrator have to cognize beforehand?</span>
*[[/Chapter 3|Chapter 3]] {{Checked by translator}}What does a demonstrator have to cognize beforehand?</span>
 
==The propositions in a demonstration==
==The propositions in a demonstration==
*[[/Chapter 4|Chapter 4]] {{Translated not checked}}Of the division of propositions required for demonstration. </span>
*[[/Chapter 4|Chapter 4]] {{Checked by translator}}Of the division of propositions required for demonstration. </span>
*[[/Chapter 5|Chapter 5]] {{Translated not checked}}On the properties of propositions required for demonstration, and how this is from indestructible things. </span>
*[[/Chapter 5|Chapter 5]] {{Checked by translator}}On the properties of propositions required for demonstration, and how this is from indestructible things. </span>
*[[/Chapter 6|Chapter 6]] {{Translated not checked}}What is ‘being of all’, and in what way can premises and conclusions of demonstrations ‘be of all’? </span>
*[[/Chapter 6|Chapter 6]] {{Checked by translator}}What is ‘being of all’, and in what way can premises and conclusions of demonstrations ‘be of all’? </span>
*[[/Chapter 7|Chapter 7]] {{Translated not checked}}In what way are propositions required for demonstration called ''per se''?</span>
*[[/Chapter 7|Chapter 7]] {{Checked by translator}}In what way are propositions required for demonstration called ''per se''?</span>
 
== Of the propositions that are necessary for demonstration ==
== Of the propositions that are necessary for demonstration ==
*[[/Chapter 8|Chapter 8]] {{Translated not checked}}What is a proposition that is ''true-primarily''? </span>
*[[/Chapter 8|Chapter 8]] {{Checked by translator}}What is a proposition that is ''true-primarily''? </span>
*[[/Chapter 9|Chapter 9]] {{Translated not checked}}On properties of a conclusion that cannot belong to all the premises.</span>
*[[/Chapter 9|Chapter 9]] {{Checked by translator}}On properties of a conclusion that cannot belong to all the premises.</span>
*[[/Chapter 10|Chapter 10]] {{Not translated}}On the way to knowing through experience</span>
*[[/Chapter 10|Chapter 10]] {{Checked by translator}}On the way to knowing through experience</span>
*[[/Chapter 11|Chapter 11]] {{Not translated}}On knowledge beforehand</span>
*[[/Chapter 11|Chapter 11]] {{Checked by translator}}On knowledge beforehand</span>
*[[/Chapter 12|Chapter 12]] {{Not translated}}What proposition can be the conclusion of a demonstration</span>
*[[/Chapter 12|Chapter 12]] {{Checked by translator}}What proposition can be the conclusion of a demonstration</span>
*[[/Chapter 13|Chapter 13]] {{Not translated}}On properties of principles involved in a demonstration</span>
*[[/Chapter 13|Chapter 13]] {{Checked by translator}}On properties of principles involved in a demonstration</span>
*[[/Chapter 14|Chapter 14]] {{Not translated}}What properties are said to be immediate</span>
*[[/Chapter 14|Chapter 14]] {{Checked by translator}}What properties are said to be immediate</span>
*[[/Chapter 15|Chapter 15]] {{Not translated}}How principles are said to be the cause of the conclusion</span>
*[[/Chapter 15|Chapter 15]] {{Checked by translator}}How principles are said to be the cause of the conclusion</span>
*[[/Chapter 16|Chapter 16]] {{Not translated}}On things that agree in general with the principles of a demonstration</span>
*[[/Chapter 16|Chapter 16]] {{Checked by translator}}On things that agree in general with the principles of a demonstration</span>


==Of demonstration itself==
==Of demonstration itself==
*[[/Chapter 17|Chapter 17]] {{Translated not checked}}On two types of demonstration: a priori and a posteriori</span>
*[[/Chapter 17|Chapter 17]] {{Checked by translator}}On two types of demonstration: a priori and a posteriori</span>
*[[/Chapter 18|Chapter 18]] {{Not translated}}On objections to what has just been said</span>
*[[/Chapter 18|Chapter 18]] {{Checked by translator}}On objections to what has just been said</span>
*[[/Chapter 19|Chapter 19]] {{Not translated}}How ''a priori'' and ''a posteriori'' demonstration differ in general</span>
*[[/Chapter 19|Chapter 19]] {{Checked by translator}}How ''a priori'' and ''a posteriori'' demonstration differ in general</span>
*[[/Chapter 20|Chapter 20]] {{Not translated}}In how many ways do ''a posteriori'' and ''a priori'' demonstration differ?</span>
*[[/Chapter 20|Chapter 20]] {{Checked by translator}}In how many ways do ''a posteriori'' and ''a priori'' demonstration differ?</span>
*[[/Chapter 21|Chapter 21]] {{Not translated}}On another difference between ''a posteriori'' and ''a priori'' demonstration</span>
*[[/Chapter 21|Chapter 21]] {{Checked by translator}}On another difference between ''a posteriori'' and ''a priori'' demonstration</span>
*[[/Chapter 22|Chapter 22]] {{Not translated}}Conclusions pertinent to this science</span>
*[[/Chapter 22|Chapter 22]] {{Checked by translator}}Conclusions pertinent to this science</span>
 
==The questions answered in demonstration==
==The questions answered in demonstration==
*[[/Chapter 23|Chapter 23]] {{Not translated}}On science and ''a priori'' demonstration and how many questions there are</span>
*[[/Chapter 23|Chapter 23]] {{Checked by translator}}On science and ''a priori'' demonstration and how many questions there are</span>
*[[/Chapter 24|Chapter 24]] {{Not translated}}On objections to what has been said</span>
*[[/Chapter 24|Chapter 24]] {{Checked by translator}}On objections to what has been said</span>
*[[/Chapter 25|Chapter 25]] {{Not translated}}How different questions may be settled in different ways</span>
*[[/Chapter 25|Chapter 25]] {{Checked by translator}}How different questions may be settled in different ways</span>
*[[/Chapter 26|Chapter 26]] {{Not translated}}On doubtful propositions about inherence</span>
*[[/Chapter 26|Chapter 26]] {{Checked by translator}}On doubtful propositions about inherence</span>
*[[/Chapter 27|Chapter 27]] {{Not translated}}Whether the being of a thing and the essence of a thing are two things outside the soul distinct from each other</span>
*[[/Chapter 27|Chapter 27]] {{Checked by translator}}Whether the being of a thing and the essence of a thing are two things outside the soul distinct from each other</span>
 
=='What something is' and demonstration==
=='What something is' and demonstration==
*[[/Chapter 28|Chapter 28]] {{Not translated}}How the question ''what is'' is settled, and first on definition</span>
*[[/Chapter 28|Chapter 28]] {{Reviewed}}'''How the question ''what is'' is settled, and first on definition</span>'''
*[[/Chapter 29|Chapter 29]] {{Not translated}}Concerning definition expressing the ''quid'' of a thing</span>
*[[/Chapter 29|Chapter 29]] {{Checked by translator}}Concerning definition expressing the ''quid'' of a thing</span>
*[[/Chapter 30|Chapter 30]] {{Not translated}}How a proposition where a difference is predicated of the absolute species can be demonstrated</span>
*[[/Chapter 30|Chapter 30]] {{Checked by translator}}How a proposition where a difference is predicated of the absolute species can be demonstrated</span>
*[[/Chapter 31|Chapter 31]] {{Not translated}}That a definition cannot be demonstrated of the defined from what is prior</span>
*[[/Chapter 31|Chapter 31]] {{Checked by translator}}That a definition cannot be demonstrated of the defined from what is prior</span>
*[[/Chapter 32|Chapter 32]] {{Not translated}}On definition given ''per additamentum'' – how is it known of what is defined?</span>
*[[/Chapter 32|Chapter 32]] {{Checked by translator}}On definition given ''per additamentum'' – how is it known of what is defined?</span>
*[[/Chapter 33|Chapter 33]] {{Not translated}}On connotative definata – how are they defined?</span>
*[[/Chapter 33|Chapter 33]] {{Checked by translator}}On connotative definata – how are they defined?</span>
*[[/Chapter 34|Chapter 34]] {{Not translated}}How can definitions of connotatives be cognised of what is defined?</span>
*[[/Chapter 34|Chapter 34]] {{Checked by translator}}How can definitions of connotatives be cognised of what is defined?</span>
 
=='Whether something is so'==
=='Whether something is so'==
*[[/Chapter 35|Chapter 35]] {{Not translated}}How the question ''quia est'' is settled ..</span>
*[[/Chapter 35|Chapter 35]] {{Checked by translator}}How the question ''quia est'' is settled ..</span>
*[[/Chapter 36|Chapter 36]] {{Not translated}}How an attribute is demonstrable of its primary subject</span>
*[[/Chapter 36|Chapter 36]] {{Checked by translator}}How an attribute is demonstrable of its primary subject</span>
*[[/Chapter 37|Chapter 37]] {{Not translated}}How an attribute can be demonstrated of the inferiors of its primary subject without any determination</span>
*[[/Chapter 37|Chapter 37]] {{Checked by translator}}How an attribute can be demonstrated of the inferiors of its primary subject without any determination</span>
*[[/Chapter 38|Chapter 38]] {{Not translated}}On an attribute conveying the same thing directly ..</span>
*[[/Chapter 38|Chapter 38]] {{Checked by translator}}On an attribute conveying the same thing directly ..</span>
*[[/Chapter 39|Chapter 39]] {{Not translated}}How it is possible to demonstrate through all causes</span>
*[[/Chapter 39|Chapter 39]] {{Checked by translator}}How it is possible to demonstrate through all causes</span>
*[[/Chapter 40|Chapter 40]] {{Not translated}}On attributes that signify obliquely part of what is signified by the subject</span>
*[[/Chapter 40|Chapter 40]] {{Checked by translator}}On attributes that signify obliquely part of what is signified by the subject</span>
 
==How the question of 'what something is', is settled==
==How the question of 'what something is', is settled==
*[[/Chapter 41|Chapter 41]] {{Not translated}}How the question ''quid est'' is settled</span>
*[[/Chapter 41|Chapter 41]] {{Checked by translator}}How the question ''quid est'' is settled</span>
 
 
[[Category:Posterior analytics]]

Latest revision as of 03:28, 25 October 2025


PART III-2: OF DEMONSTRATION

Colour codes

Chapter headings are colour coded to indicate the stage of the translation process. 'Reviewed' means that another competent translator has checked the work section by section. 'Authorised' means that a member of a specialist panel has reviewed the whole translation, and approved it.

Terms and the conditions required of them in order that their propositions form part of demonstration

  • Chapter 1 What is understood by the term "demonstration," and in how many ways is "to know" predicated?
  • Chapter 2 What terms are included in a demonstration?
  • Chapter 3 What does a demonstrator have to cognize beforehand?

The propositions in a demonstration

  • Chapter 4 Of the division of propositions required for demonstration.
  • Chapter 5 On the properties of propositions required for demonstration, and how this is from indestructible things.
  • Chapter 6 What is ‘being of all’, and in what way can premises and conclusions of demonstrations ‘be of all’?
  • Chapter 7 In what way are propositions required for demonstration called per se?

Of the propositions that are necessary for demonstration

  • Chapter 8 What is a proposition that is true-primarily?
  • Chapter 9 On properties of a conclusion that cannot belong to all the premises.
  • Chapter 10 On the way to knowing through experience
  • Chapter 11 On knowledge beforehand
  • Chapter 12 What proposition can be the conclusion of a demonstration
  • Chapter 13 On properties of principles involved in a demonstration
  • Chapter 14 What properties are said to be immediate
  • Chapter 15 How principles are said to be the cause of the conclusion
  • Chapter 16 On things that agree in general with the principles of a demonstration

Of demonstration itself

  • Chapter 17 On two types of demonstration: a priori and a posteriori
  • Chapter 18 On objections to what has just been said
  • Chapter 19 How a priori and a posteriori demonstration differ in general
  • Chapter 20 In how many ways do a posteriori and a priori demonstration differ?
  • Chapter 21 On another difference between a posteriori and a priori demonstration
  • Chapter 22 Conclusions pertinent to this science

The questions answered in demonstration

  • Chapter 23 On science and a priori demonstration and how many questions there are
  • Chapter 24 On objections to what has been said
  • Chapter 25 How different questions may be settled in different ways
  • Chapter 26 On doubtful propositions about inherence
  • Chapter 27 Whether the being of a thing and the essence of a thing are two things outside the soul distinct from each other

'What something is' and demonstration

  • Chapter 28 How the question what is is settled, and first on definition
  • Chapter 29 Concerning definition expressing the quid of a thing
  • Chapter 30 How a proposition where a difference is predicated of the absolute species can be demonstrated
  • Chapter 31 That a definition cannot be demonstrated of the defined from what is prior
  • Chapter 32 On definition given per additamentum – how is it known of what is defined?
  • Chapter 33 On connotative definata – how are they defined?
  • Chapter 34 How can definitions of connotatives be cognised of what is defined?

'Whether something is so'

  • Chapter 35 How the question quia est is settled ..
  • Chapter 36 How an attribute is demonstrable of its primary subject
  • Chapter 37 How an attribute can be demonstrated of the inferiors of its primary subject without any determination
  • Chapter 38 On an attribute conveying the same thing directly ..
  • Chapter 39 How it is possible to demonstrate through all causes
  • Chapter 40 On attributes that signify obliquely part of what is signified by the subject

How the question of 'what something is', is settled