Translations into medieval Latin: Difference between revisions

From The Logic Museum
Jump to navigation Jump to search
No edit summary
 
(14 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
==Earliest translations==
==Earliest translations==
''Earliest translations of Greek, Hebrew, and Arabic works into Latin'' (from ''The Cambridge Companion to Medieval Philosophy'',  ed. A. S. McGrade, Cambridge 2003, p.44).
Adapted from "Earliest translations of Greek, Hebrew, and Arabic works into Latin" (from ''The Cambridge Companion to Medieval Philosophy'',  ed. A. S. McGrade, Cambridge 2003, p.44).


{| border=1 cellpadding=10
{| border=1 cellpadding=10 class="wikitable sortable"
!valign = top width=20%|Author
!valign = top width=10%|Author
!valign = top width=20%|Work
!valign = top width=20%|Work
!valign = top width=20%|Translator
!valign = top width=25%|Translator
!valign = top width=20%|Date
!valign = top width=10%|Date
!valign = top width=20%|Modern editions
!valign = top width=35%|Modern editions
|- valign = top
|- valign = top
|Plato
|Plato
Line 15: Line 15:
|Calodius
|Calodius


|c. 400
|0400 c.


|
|
Line 26: Line 26:
|Boethius
|Boethius


|c. 510-22
|0510-22 c.  


|[[Authors/Boethius/categories]]
|[[Authors/Boethius/categories|Boethius:Categories]]


|- valign = top
|- valign = top
Line 37: Line 37:
|Boethius
|Boethius


|c. 510-22
|0510-22 c.  


|[[Authors/Boethius/Periherm]]
|[[Authors/Boethius/Periherm|Boethius:Perihermenias]]


|- valign = top
|- valign = top
Line 48: Line 48:
|Boethius
|Boethius


|c. 510-22
|0510-22 c.  


|[[Authors/Boethius/TrPA]]
|[[Authors/Boethius/TrPA|Boethius:Prior Analytics]]


|- valign = top
|- valign = top
Line 59: Line 59:
|James of Venice
|James of Venice


|? 1125-50
|1125-50 ?


|[[Aristoteles Latinus|''Analytica posteriora'']]. Translationes Iacobi, edd. L. Minio-Paluello et B.G. Dod, Desclée De Brouwer, Bruges-Paris 1968.
|[[Aristoteles Latinus|''Analytica posteriora'']]. Translationes Iacobi, edd. L. Minio-Paluello et B.G. Dod, Desclée De Brouwer, Bruges-Paris 1968.
Line 70: Line 70:
|Boethius
|Boethius


|c. 510-22
|0510-22 c.  


|
|
Line 81: Line 81:
|Boethius
|Boethius


|c. 510-22
|0510-22 c.  


|
|
Line 92: Line 92:
|James of Venice
|James of Venice


|? 1125-50
|1125-50 ?


|[[Aristoteles Latinus|''Physica'', Translatio Vetus]], edd. F. Bossier et J. Brams
|[[Aristoteles Latinus|''Physica'', Translatio Vetus]], edd. F. Bossier et J. Brams
Line 103: Line 103:
|James of Venice
|James of Venice


|? 1125-50
|1125-50 ?


|
|
Line 114: Line 114:
|Michael Scot
|Michael Scot


|c. 1220-24
|1220-24 c.


|
|
Line 125: Line 125:
|Robert Grosseteste
|Robert Grosseteste


|• 1246-47
| 1246-47


|
|
Line 136: Line 136:
|William of Moerbeke
|William of Moerbeke


|• 1260
| 1260


|
|
Line 147: Line 147:
|Boethius
|Boethius


|c. 510-22
|0510-22 c.  


|[[Authors/Porphyry/isagoge]]
|[[Authors/Porphyry/isagoge| Porphyry:Isagoge]]


|- valign = top
|- valign = top
Line 169: Line 169:
|Gerard of Cremona
|Gerard of Cremona


|before 1187
|1187 (before)


|
|
Line 180: Line 180:
|Scottus Eriugena
|Scottus Eriugena


|862
|0862


|
|
Line 191: Line 191:
|Dominicus Gundisalvi
|Dominicus Gundisalvi


|after 1150
|1150 (after )


|
|
Line 202: Line 202:
|Ibn Daoud and Dominicus Gundisalvi
|Ibn Daoud and Dominicus Gundisalvi


|after 1152
|1152 (after )


|
|
Line 213: Line 213:
|Iohannes Hispanus and Dominicus Gundisalvi
|Iohannes Hispanus and Dominicus Gundisalvi


|after 1152
|1152 (after)


|
|
Line 225: Line 225:
|Anonymous
|Anonymous


|c. 1230
|1230 c.  


|
|
Line 237: Line 237:
|Michael Scot
|Michael Scot


|c. 1220-35
|1220-35 c.


|
|
Line 248: Line 248:
|Michael Scot
|Michael Scot


|c.1220-24
|1220-24 c.


|
|
Line 259: Line 259:
|Michael Scot
|Michael Scot


|c.1220-24
|1220-24 c.


|
|
Line 270: Line 270:
|Herman the German
|Herman the German


|? 1240
|1240 ?


|
|


|}
|}
<noinclude>
 
==Notes==
{{reflist}}</noinclude>
==The Metaphysics==
==The Metaphysics==
It was only in the early 13th century, when Michael Scot translated the Arabic version contained in Averroe's Long Commentary on the Metaphysics (the so-called ''Metaphysica Nova''), that the text became fully available in the Latin West, some time after a tradition of commentaries on the ''Categories'' had been established. Most of the early English commentaries are based on the ''Metaphysica Nova''.
It was only in the early 13th century, when Michael Scot translated the Arabic version contained in Averroes Long Commentary on the Metaphysics (the so-called ''Metaphysica Nova''), that the text became fully available in the Latin West, some time after a tradition of commentaries on the ''Categories'' had been established. Most of the early English commentaries are based on the ''Metaphysica Nova''<ref>[[Amerini & Galluzzo 2013]] p.138</ref>.
*''Metaphysica Vetustissima'', ascribed to James of Venice. See [[Aristoteles Latinus]] XXV. Contains only the first four books.  A highly literal translation, even down to the word order. Although he sometimes translates the same Greek word with different Latin words, he systematically translates the key terms in a fixed way, sometimes deferring to Boethius's vocabulary.
*''Metaphysica Vetustissima'', ascribed to James of Venice. See [[Aristoteles Latinus]] XXV. Contains only the first four books.  A highly literal translation, even down to the word order. Although he sometimes translates the same Greek word with different Latin words, he systematically translates the key terms in a fixed way, sometimes deferring to Boethius's vocabulary.
*''Metaphysica Vetus'', probably a revision of James's translation.  
*''Metaphysica Vetus'', probably a revision of James's translation.  
* ''Metaphysica Media'', also known as ''Translatio anonyma''. A second translation from the Greek (the Translatio Media) seems to have been used by Albert the Great as the basis of his commentary.” See [[Aristoteles Latinus]] XXV.  It contains lib. I-X, XII-XIV. The translation is anonymous, but a close relationship has been demonstrated between the Media and the Translatio Vaticana of the ''Physics''", an anonymous translation dating back probably to the second half of the 12th century. Reading 'Canoniensis' as 'Cremononsis', Minio-Paluello tentatively ascribes it to Gerard of Cremona (d.1187), best known as a translator from Arabic into Latin. See "Latin Medieval Translations of Aristotle's ''Metaphysics''", Marta Borgo, [[Amerini & Galluzzo 2013]] p. 37 ff.
* ''Metaphysica Media'', also known as ''Translatio anonyma''. A second translation from the Greek (the ''Translatio Media'') seems to have been used by Albert the Great as the basis of his commentary. See [[Aristoteles Latinus]] XXV.  It contains lib. I-X, XII-XIV. The translation is anonymous, but a close relationship has been demonstrated between the Media and the ''Translatio Vaticana'' of the ''Physics''", an anonymous translation dating back probably to the second half of the 12th century. Reading 'Canoniensis' as 'Cremononsis', Minio-Paluello tentatively ascribes it to Gerard of Cremona (d.1187), best known as a translator from Arabic into Latin. See "Latin Medieval Translations of Aristotle's ''Metaphysics''", Marta Borgo, [[Amerini & Galluzzo 2013]] p. 37 ff.
* ''Metaphysica Nova'': Aristotle's text taken from the translation of Averroes' commentary, probably by Michael Scot, 1220s<ref> [[Amerini & Galluzzo 2013]] p. 49</ref>.  The first complete translation of the Metaphysics.  
* ''Metaphysica Nova'': Aristotle's text taken from the translation of Averroes' commentary, probably by Michael Scot, 1220s<ref> [[Amerini & Galluzzo 2013]] p. 49</ref>.  The first complete translation of the Metaphysics.
===William of Moerbeke===
In the second half of the 13th century the translations from the Greek of many Aristotelian writings and the revisions of earlier Greek translations were mostly by William of Moerbeke. William was born ca. 1215 or later in the village of Moerbeke, now in Belgium, and probably entered the Dominican convent at Louvain as a young man.  He was probably a member of the Dominican convent established at Thebes in Greece in the 1250s - a manuscript colophon records that his translation of Alexander's commentary on the ''Meteorologica'' was completed at Nicea in April 1260, another records the completion of ''De animalibus'' at Thebes in December 1260. By 1271 he held the chaplain and confessor to the pope at the papal court at Viterbo. Manuscript colophons record that two of his translations were made in Viterbo in 1267 and 1268.  He was one of the chief Greek interpreters at the Second Council of Lyons (1272-4).  He stayed at the court until 1278, when he was made Archbishop of Corinth in Greece, dying there in 1286<ref> Mainly sourced from Fryde, E. (''The Early Palaeologan Renaissance (1261-c. 1360)'', chapter 7 pp 103.ff.</ref>. 
Moerbeke was clearly not the first to translate the ''Metaphysics'' from the Greek, but his translation was widely used in the late 12th and early 13th centuries – it supposedly was the basis of Aquinas's commentary on the work.  The following editions of his work are in [[Aristoteles Latinus]].
*''Metaphysica'': libri I - X; XII - XIII.2 (translationis ‘mediae’ recensio), XXV.3, pars secunda, ed. G. Vuillemin-Diem, 1995, p. 11-320
*''Metaphysica'': libri XI; XIII.2 - XIV, A.L. XXV.3, pars secunda, ed. G. Vuillemin-Diem, 1995, p. 11-320
 
==See also==
*[[Authors/Thomas Aquinas/metaphysics|Aquinas: Commentary on the ''Metaphysics'']]
*[[Commentaries on the Metaphysics|Commentaries on the ''Metaphysics'']]
*[[Authors/Aristotle/metaphysics|Aristotle:''Metaphysics'']]


==Notes==
==Notes==

Latest revision as of 03:06, 25 March 2016

Earliest translations

Adapted from "Earliest translations of Greek, Hebrew, and Arabic works into Latin" (from The Cambridge Companion to Medieval Philosophy, ed. A. S. McGrade, Cambridge 2003, p.44).

Author Work Translator Date Modern editions
Plato Timaeus Calodius 0400 c.
Aristotle Categories Boethius 0510-22 c. Boethius:Categories
De interpretatione Boethius 0510-22 c. Boethius:Perihermenias
Prior Analytics Boethius 0510-22 c. Boethius:Prior Analytics
Posterior Analytics James of Venice 1125-50 ? Analytica posteriora. Translationes Iacobi, edd. L. Minio-Paluello et B.G. Dod, Desclée De Brouwer, Bruges-Paris 1968.
Topics Boethius 0510-22 c.
Sophistical Refutations Boethius 0510-22 c.
Physics James of Venice 1125-50 ? Physica, Translatio Vetus, edd. F. Bossier et J. Brams
De anima James of Venice 1125-50 ?
Metaphysics (nearly complete) Michael Scot 1220-24 c.
Nicomachean Ethics (complete) Robert Grosseteste 1246-47
Politics William of Moerbeke 1260
Porphyry Introduction (isagoge) Boethius 0510-22 c. Porphyry:Isagoge
Proclus Elements of Theology William of Moerbeke 1268
Anonymous Liber de causis (drawn from Proclus) Gerard of Cremona 1187 (before)
Ps.-Dionysius Mystical Treatises Scottus Eriugena 0862
Ibn Sina (Avicenna) Metaphysics [Book of Healing IV) Dominicus Gundisalvi 1150 (after )
De anima (Book of Healing III.6) Ibn Daoud and Dominicus Gundisalvi 1152 (after )
Ihn Cabirol Fountain of Life Iohannes Hispanus and Dominicus Gundisalvi 1152 (after)
Maimonides Guide for the

Perplexed

Anonymous 1230 c.
Ibn Rushd (Averroes) Great Commentary on

Aristotle's Physics

Michael Scot 1220-35 c.
Great Commentary on Aristotle's De anima Michael Scot 1220-24 c.
Great Commentary on Aristotle's Metaphysics Michael Scot 1220-24 c.
Middle Commentary on Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics Herman the German 1240 ?

The Metaphysics

It was only in the early 13th century, when Michael Scot translated the Arabic version contained in Averroes Long Commentary on the Metaphysics (the so-called Metaphysica Nova), that the text became fully available in the Latin West, some time after a tradition of commentaries on the Categories had been established. Most of the early English commentaries are based on the Metaphysica Nova[1].

  • Metaphysica Vetustissima, ascribed to James of Venice. See Aristoteles Latinus XXV. Contains only the first four books. A highly literal translation, even down to the word order. Although he sometimes translates the same Greek word with different Latin words, he systematically translates the key terms in a fixed way, sometimes deferring to Boethius's vocabulary.
  • Metaphysica Vetus, probably a revision of James's translation.
  • Metaphysica Media, also known as Translatio anonyma. A second translation from the Greek (the Translatio Media) seems to have been used by Albert the Great as the basis of his commentary. See Aristoteles Latinus XXV. It contains lib. I-X, XII-XIV. The translation is anonymous, but a close relationship has been demonstrated between the Media and the Translatio Vaticana of the Physics", an anonymous translation dating back probably to the second half of the 12th century. Reading 'Canoniensis' as 'Cremononsis', Minio-Paluello tentatively ascribes it to Gerard of Cremona (d.1187), best known as a translator from Arabic into Latin. See "Latin Medieval Translations of Aristotle's Metaphysics", Marta Borgo, Amerini & Galluzzo 2013 p. 37 ff.
  • Metaphysica Nova: Aristotle's text taken from the translation of Averroes' commentary, probably by Michael Scot, 1220s[2]. The first complete translation of the Metaphysics.

William of Moerbeke

In the second half of the 13th century the translations from the Greek of many Aristotelian writings and the revisions of earlier Greek translations were mostly by William of Moerbeke. William was born ca. 1215 or later in the village of Moerbeke, now in Belgium, and probably entered the Dominican convent at Louvain as a young man. He was probably a member of the Dominican convent established at Thebes in Greece in the 1250s - a manuscript colophon records that his translation of Alexander's commentary on the Meteorologica was completed at Nicea in April 1260, another records the completion of De animalibus at Thebes in December 1260. By 1271 he held the chaplain and confessor to the pope at the papal court at Viterbo. Manuscript colophons record that two of his translations were made in Viterbo in 1267 and 1268. He was one of the chief Greek interpreters at the Second Council of Lyons (1272-4). He stayed at the court until 1278, when he was made Archbishop of Corinth in Greece, dying there in 1286[3]. Moerbeke was clearly not the first to translate the Metaphysics from the Greek, but his translation was widely used in the late 12th and early 13th centuries – it supposedly was the basis of Aquinas's commentary on the work. The following editions of his work are in Aristoteles Latinus.

  • Metaphysica: libri I - X; XII - XIII.2 (translationis ‘mediae’ recensio), XXV.3, pars secunda, ed. G. Vuillemin-Diem, 1995, p. 11-320
  • Metaphysica: libri XI; XIII.2 - XIV, A.L. XXV.3, pars secunda, ed. G. Vuillemin-Diem, 1995, p. 11-320

See also

Notes

  1. ↑ Amerini & Galluzzo 2013 p.138
  2. ↑ Amerini & Galluzzo 2013 p. 49
  3. ↑ Mainly sourced from Fryde, E. (The Early Palaeologan Renaissance (1261-c. 1360), chapter 7 pp 103.ff.